Homemade 4 Cheese Mac & Cheese on the Stovetop 2

Homemade 4 Cheese Mac & Cheese on the Stovetop

Sharing is caring!

This post was sponsored by Heluva Good! Cheese as part of an Influence Central campaign and all opinions expressed in my post are my own.

Do you like macaroni and cheese? It’s one of our favorite foods and I’m always looking for new ways to prepare it. And sure, it’s just as easy to buy a boxed mix but why not make it from scratch? I recently tried out a twist on a favorite recipe for a four cheese macaroni and cheese on the stove.

Homemade 4 Cheese Mac & Cheese on the Stovetop 3

And when I say 4 cheese? I mean 4 cheese. It makes for a cheesy but not overwhelmingly cheesy dish that’s ready in less than half an hour.

Serve it on the side, for a quick lunch option, or make it into a main dish by adding a protein like chicken or ground beef. Whatever you decide to do, this delicious homemade mac and cheese will be a go-to for your family as well- I’m sure.

Homemade 4 Cheese Mac & Cheese on the Stovetop 4

You can, of course, use other types of cheese- in fact, I would encourage you to do so. But, knowing my Squeaker the way that I do; I didn’t want to take it too over the top.

One of the best ways I can do this though is to have her help me with shopping.

We were at our local WalMart anyway to pick up pasta and a few other things. So we stopped by the cheese wall. And by shopping here, you can also take advantage of the limited Ibotta rebate offer. There is no expiration for this offer, but once the rebates are gone- they’re gone.

Homemade 4 Cheese Mac & Cheese on the Stovetop 5

We love stopping at our local Italian market for their cheese table, so stopping near the cheese wall was nothing out of the ordinary for us. Now, it was just a matter of picking out our cheeses for the macaroni and cheese. I didn’t want to overwhelm her too much but here are the varieties that Heluva Good!® has:

  • Colby Jack
  • Pepper Jack
  • Extra Sharp Cheddar
  • Sharp Cheddar
  • White Extra Sharp Cheddar
  • White Sharp Cheddar
  • White Mild Cheddar
  • Muenster
  • Monterey Jack
  • Special Reserve Extra Sharp Cheddar
  • Colby
  • Mild Cheddar

I knew that I wanted to make some homemade queso dip later, so I picked up a Heluva Good! Block Cheese in Pepper Jack and Jalapeno Jack. This was in addition to our choices for the macaroni and cheese: Colby Jack, White Mild Cheddar, Special Reserve Extra Sharp Cheddar, and Extra Sharp Cheddar.

We also picked up a child-friendly grater so Squeaker could help me with more of the preparation.

Homemade 4 Cheese Mac & Cheese on the Stovetop 6

I love the fact that Heluva Good is gluten free so if I could make the entire recipe gluten free if needed.

Here’s the recipe:

Yield: 6

4 Cheese Macaroni and Cheese

4 Cheese Macaroni and Cheese

This easy homemade 4 cheese mac & cheese is made on the stove top and in under 30 minutes.

Prep Time 10 minutes
Cook Time 20 minutes
Total Time 30 minutes


  • 1 package pasta of choice
  • 1/8 block cheese (shredded), 4 1/8 sized pieces total
  • 3 tbsp butter
  • 3/4 cup milk
  • 2 tbsp flour


  1. Prepare pasta according to package directions and in the meantime, shred your chosen cheeses.
  2. When pasta is ready to drain, measure out the milk.
  3. You can either just drain the water and leave the pasta in the pot or drain it separately
  4. If draining separately, melt the butter in the pasta pan and add the flour. Stir until well incorporated and then add milk. Add shredded cheeses. Then add salt and pepper to taste.
  5. Return the pasta to the pan and mix until coated with the cheese sauce.


Homemade 4 Cheese Mac & Cheese on the Stovetop 8

The following two tabs change content below.


Content Creator at Kori at Home
Kori is an autistic mom who also happens to have ADHD and Anxiety. She is currently located in Albany, NY where she is raising a neurodivergent family. Her older daughter is non-speaking autistic (and also has ADHD and Anxiety) and her youngest daughter is HSP/Gifted. As an empath, HSP, and highly intuitive individual, Kori brings her own life experiences as an autistic woman combined with her adventures in momming to bring you the day-to-day of her life at home. Kori provides life coaching services for neurodivergent women (and those who identify as women) as well as Oracle card reading, Tarot card readings, and energy healing.
Notify of
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Skip to Recipe
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
Scroll to Top