Sharing is caring!

Should Christian’s Celebrate Halloween? Here’s a Faith Filled Approach

By Guest Poster- Traci Rhoades from Traces of Faith

Traci's adorable daughter
Traci’s adorable daughter

Let me start by saying I have no haunting tales from my own childhood Halloween experiences. It never spooked me. Seeing the scary costumes didn’t impact me one way or the other. Attending the haunted house set up in the sanctuary of my church might seem a bit strange now, but I thought nothing of it at the time.


So when we had our daughter, my husband and I weighed the pros and cons of Halloween. As parents. Together, we decided we would not celebrate this holiday.


A quick Internet search will enlighten you about the evening’s history. Actually, our research taught us that most holidays have a pagan beginning. Historically, the church would start their own holiday as a way of breaking away from many of the pagan celebratory acts. There are pagan holidays celebrated around Easter, Christmas and yes, Halloween.


Further, some of these religious holidays are no longer celebrated by the church at large. All Saints Day, on November 1st, honors the lives of saints who have died before us. Some Catholics still participate in this day but by and large, Christians don’t know it exists.


I know, T.M.I. But this shows you how seriously we took our decision. I knew a day would come when my daughter wanted to know why we didn’t participate in Halloween, and I wanted to be ready with an educated answer.


Intentional parenting.


Fast forward a few years. Most of our family thought we’d gone overboard on the Halloween boycott. We had friends who celebrated and those who didn’t. My sister-in-law casually invited us to a Fall Festival Party downtown on the weekend of Halloween. And a lot of justifying started happening. It wasn’t on the day of Halloween. It was downtown, very safe. We received candy at parades so what made this any different? My mother-in-law just happened to still have a clown costume my husband wore as a toddler. Nothing scary.


We participated.


Each year, I would dread Halloween as it approached because I knew my daughter was starting to put together the fact that there was a great big party she didn’t get an invitation to. Because her parents said no.


Finally, it all came to a head her preschool year at a parochial school. She didn’t attend the school party.


Then, the week of Halloween, a friend from back home posted an article on why Christians SHOULD celebrate Halloween. A perspective that changed my way of thinking. The article suggested that as believers, we do enough hiding out from the world. Perhaps the best way to be the salt and the light God called us to be is by joining in on the fun. The fun. Not the scary, dark side of Halloween.


It encouraged readers to find ways to show God’s love in their Halloween activities. If you live in a subdivision, be the house where people go for a chili supper or a hayride after they trick or treat. Rather than a trunk-or-treat event at your church, hand out candy in the neighborhoods where you live. Use the night as an opportunity to shine for Jesus.


Following is my friend’s response in our exchange about the article:

“I like the idea of Christians being part of their community. What a wonderful opportunity to meet and be with your neighbors! It’s really the only holiday that gets everyone out of their houses and outside talking to people. I say make it a party! Hand out chili, hot cocoa, show a movie on your garage door. In others words make your house the place to be and develop relationships with folks. If all the Christians start going to the Trunk-or-Treats…which seems to be Trick or Treating…just at church, what good does that do?“


This, this, I could chew on as a possibility. I called a girlfriend of mine and told her we might be thinking about joining her on Halloween….


And here’s what we’ve decided to do. We do the classroom party at school. Our daughter dresses up in a non-scary costume (thus far we’ve gone from one princess to another princess to another). Halloween night, we head downtown where businesses hand out candy to kids before it gets dark. We print up an applicable Bible verse and she hands them out to each person who gives her a piece of candy. We end up at a local church who serves a hot dog dinner. Finally, we go to our friends’ house for chili and dessert. A very fun evening that makes my daughter very happy.


Call it a compromise. Definitely a change in opinion from our early days of parenting. But one we are all satisfied with for now.


In a way, I guess you could say we took Halloween back. It’s still not my favorite night of the year. We’ve made it a holiday in good standing with the beliefs we try to instill in our daughter. And every year, we stay on the lookout for ways to glorify God on this day too. Because after all, it was His day first.


This is the day that the Lord has made; I will rejoice and be glad in it.

Proverbs 118:24

About Traci:

I’m here to encourage readers to trace God at work in their everyday faith. I write over at . Contact me on Facebook: Or on Twitter:



Article Link:

The following two tabs change content below.


Digital Product Creator at Kori at Home
Kori is a late diagnosed autistic/ADHD mom. She is currently located in Albany, NY where she is raising a neurodiverse family. Her older daughter is non-speaking autistic (and also has ADHD and Anxiety) and her youngest daughter is HSP/Gifted. A blogger, podcaster, writer, product creator, and coach; Kori shares autism family life- the highs, lows, messy, and real. Kori brings her own life experiences as an autistic woman combined with her adventures in momming to bring you the day-to-day of her life at home. Kori is on a mission to empower moms of autistic children to make informed parenting decisions with confidence and conviction.

Similar Posts

Notify of
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
9 years ago

We do Halloween, but the kiddo can’t dress up as anything mean or evil, even when he’s older. By the way, ALL Catholics (at least the ones who attend Mass regularly) celebrate All Saints Day. It’s a Holy Day of Obligation for us. 🙂

Reply to  Kori
9 years ago

Didn’t know that! Super cool!

9 years ago

I’m glad you’ve found a way to create a positive experience that works with your beliefs! It can be hard to find a way to connect with popular culture that’s authentic to who you are, no matter what your religion.

Kelly Lessard
9 years ago

I agree with this article one hundred percent!!!

9 years ago

We do Halloween, because I think it has great components to it. I think walking around within your neighborhood and getting to see the neighbors has a value to it. I make sure that my kids are well educated about God and our beliefs. The two have never been contrary to each other. If it becomes anything other than fun, and fellowship, then it will stop.